Saturday 16 August 2008

STATEMENT BY THE CHRI MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS

STATEMENT BY THE CHRI MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS

Aug, 13th 2008
CHECHENPRESS.

Official Information Section, 09/08/08

Following the recent events in the Caucasus and the beginning of theopen aggression by the Russian Federation against the sovereign Republicof Georgia the ChRI Ministry of Foreign Affairs makes the followingstatement:

The Chechen people who have been fighting for their freedom for severalcenturies against the Russian occupying forces consider Russia’saggression against Georgia a disgusting and misanthropic act aimed atescalating the military conflicts in the whole Caucasus.
There isn’t andthere cannot be any justification for Russia’s acts of aggressionbecause military conflicts are a source of infinite suffering for thecivilian population of the conflicting parties.
The Chechen people who in fact have been victims of Russia’s aggressivegeopolitical ambitions have in reality been sacrificed by theinternational community to the Kremlin Empire. Ichkeriya’s leadershiphave always been staunch supporters of the peaceful resolution of theRussian-Chechen military conflict and have repeatedly informed the mainpolitical actors in the region, as well as their partners, of Russia’splans to annex the territories of neighbouring countries.
The war crimeswhich Russia commits in the ChRI and which have been criminally ignored by the whole world only serve to stimulate the far-reaching goals of theKremlin. Leading countries of the world have left these warnings withoutheed hoping to satisfy Russia’s revengeful appetites with the Chechenblood. However, as the Russian forces’ open intervention in Georgia demonstrates Russia’s imperial aspirations are but growing and itsaggressiveness is gathering new and dangerous momentum.
This alarming situation has motivated the ChRI leadership to urge allpeace loving countries to exercise their principled approach and toprevent further escalation of the military conflict by reigning in theaggressor.
The ChRI Minister of Foreign AffairsUsman Ferzauli

Minsk Silence on S. Ossetia

13 August 2008

Minsk Silence on S. Ossetia

MINSK -- Russia's ambassador to Belarus said Tuesday that Moscow couldnot understand why Minsk, nominally a close ally, had failed to offerthe Kremlin open support in its conflict with Georgia.
"We are somewhat perplexed by the modest silence of the Belarussian side. You need to express yourself more clearly on such issues,"Ambassador Alexander Surikov told a briefing.
Belarus' Foreign Ministry has called on both sides to lay down theirarms and start negotiating for peace.Surikov complained that Belarus had not even offered to send aid forpeople injured or made homeless in South Ossetia. "We have alwayssupported and defended Belarus," he said. (Reuters)

Stand up to Russia

Stand up to Russia

Sending troops to help Georgia is out of the question, but the U.S.must do more than issue strongly worded statements.

By Max Boot

The Los Angeles Times August 12, 2008

It took the Red Army -- excuse me, the Russian army -- only two daysto secure Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Now Russia is pressing itsattacks into the heart of Georgia, threatening to cut the majoreast-west highway and vital oil pipeline. Moscow's ultimate goalremains unclear, but it may well be to topple the democraticallyelected government of President Mikheil Saakashvili and replace himwith a pro-Kremlin stooge. That is what the Russians did in Chechnyain 1999-2000.

The difference is that, while Chechnya had aspirations of nationhood,Georgia has already achieved it. Since the collapse of the Sovietempire in 1991, it has been a fully sovereign country. More recently,as a result of the 2003 Rose Revolution, Georgia has become ademocracy -- admittedly an imperfect democracy, but with far greaterrule of law than Russia. By crossing Georgia's borders, the Russianshave committed their worst violation of international law since theinvasion of Afghanistan in 1979.

At a time like this, it is vital for the leaders of the West to standtogether and make clear that this aggression will not stand. This isno time for weaselly statements of moral equivalence claiming thatGeorgia brought this war on itself or that Russia's response is merely"disproportionate" -- as if there were a "proportionate" level ofaggression that would be justified. Whatever the details of the clashthat began last week between Georgia and the breakaway, pro-Russiaprovince of South Ossetia, there can be no excuse for Russia'sinvasion. The presidents of Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia and Poland wereon the mark in their demand that "aggression against a small countryin Europe ... not be passed over in silence or with meaninglessstatements equating the victims with the victimizers.

"The more hysterical excuses that Moscow makes for its aggression areparticularly creepy. Pravda accuses Saakashvili of committing "warcrimes against humanity" and claims that Russia had no choice but toprotect its citizens in South Ossetia from a "savage, brutal, criminalattack" by "the back-stabbing Georgians." There are echoes here ofGerman spokesmen from the 1930s shedding crocodile tears over thesupposed mistreatment of German minorities in nearby states. Thosewere the excuses that Hitler used to swallow Czechoslovakia and Poland.

The Nazi analogy may appear overwrought. Certainly no one is claimingthat Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin is another Hitler, auniquely evil and reckless madman. But Putin does appear to have morethan a passing resemblance to lesser autocrats such as Mussolini andthe Japanese generals of the 1930s whose aggression nevertheless hadtragic repercussions. Indeed, two other historical analogies that cometo mind are the Japanese invasion of Manchuria in 1931 and the Italianinvasion of Ethiopia in 1935. Both set the stage for World War II byrevealing the impotence of the League of Nations and the unwillingnessof the great powers to respond forcefully to aggression.Likewise, the Russian attacks on Georgia, if left unchecked, couldeasily trigger more conflict in the future. The Kremlin has embarkedon a campaign to destabilize not just pro-Western Georgia but otherformer Soviet satrapies that refuse to toe its line. Many of thesestates have their own Russian minorities whose alleged maltreatmentprovides the perfect excuse for Russian meddling. Today, Georgia;tomorrow, Ukraine; the day after, Estonia?

If there is one thing that has limited Russian action against theBaltic states to cyber-attacks, economic pressure and verbal bullying,it is that these countries are now part of NATO. NATO's refusal togive Georgia a "membership action plan" earlier this year was ablunder that emboldened Russian aggression. That is a mistake thaturgently needs to be rectified.The West must demand that Russia withdraw its troops from all of Georgia's soil, possibly to be replaced in South Ossetia and Abkhaziawith international peacekeepers. If the Kremlin won't comply, the Westshould respond with sanctions such as withdrawing ambassadors fromMoscow, kicking Russia out of the Group of 8 leading industrializednations and freezing Russian bank accounts abroadWe should also do more to help Georgia defend itself. Sending Americantroops is out of the question, but we can send American equipment.

That's what we did in 1973 when Israel appeared on the verge of losingthe Yom Kippur War, and it is a favor we should extend to ourembattled ally in the Caucasus. The greatest bang for the buck wouldcome from two inexpensive hand-held missiles: the Stinger to destroyRussian aircraft and the Javelin to destroy tanks. Pictures of longcolumns of Russian vehicles advancing slowly down winding mountainroads indicate that a few well-placed missiles could wreak havoc withtheir operations.

Many will claim that such steps are needlessly "provocative" and thatthe fate of Georgia is inconsequential beside the larger imperative ofmaintaining good relations with Russia. We have heard such talkbefore. The world failed in the 1930s to rally to the defense of smallstates such as Ethiopia, Poland, Czechoslovakia and Finland when theywere menaced by larger predators. The statesman of the time calculatedthat the cost of action was too high. What we learned in retrospectwas that the cost of inaction was far higher. That is a lesson weshould heed today.

Max Boot is a contributing editor to Opinion and the Jeane J.Kirkpatrick senior fellow in national security studies at the Councilon Foreign Relations.

Putin Outmaneuvers the West

Der Spiegel 08/12/2008

CEASEFIRE IN GEORGIA

Putin Outmaneuvers the West

By Christian Neef
Russia's strongman Vladimir Putin has achieved his goal in Georgia --the country has been destabilized. And the West will have to look onpowerless when its ally, Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili, iseventually driven from office.
The march on Tbilisi has been called off, if such plans ever existed.Russian President Dimitry Medvedev has announced the end of militaryoperations in the Caucasus for the time being. According to sources inMoscow, some in the Russian military found it very painful to have tohalt the advance just 90 kilometers from the office of GeorgianPresident Mikhail Saakashvili. The hardliners would have loved nothingmore than to do a bit of clearing up in the headquarters of thisGeorgian hothead.
But hasn't Russia already achieved everything it had set out toachieve? Moscow will now argue that it has fulfilled its "peacekeepingmission" as Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin puts it, and that ithas stuck to international agreements regarding the Caucasus byprotecting one side and restraining the other. Now only one taskremains -- Saakashvili needs to go, say the Russians.And that poses the next quandary for the West. Russia will now stressits readiness to enter negotiations, but only on one condition -- thatSaakashvili quits. The Russians will demand that the West (andespecially the Americans) let their their darling go.
Russia had already indicated its position on Monday when Putin drewparallels between Saakashvili and Saddam Hussein. One could understandthat the Americans had hanged the criminal Saddam, said Putin. But headded that it was a scandal that the US had a totally different stancein the case of Saakashvilli and had even provided eight aircraft totransport the Georgian soldiers stationed in Iraq to join the fightingin Georgia.
So Moscow is calling for Saakashvili's head as a precondition forresolving the conflict -- and the West dearly wants a resolution. Butthe West accedes to Moscow's demand, it will publicly embarrassitself. On the other hand such an outcome would be logical. Ascolumnist Bruce Anderson wrote in Britain's Independent newspaper: "Indiplomacy, strategy and geopolitics, our political leaders have beenguilty of multiple failures over many years." All the talk about apossible Georgian membership of NATO only encouraged Tbilisi to embarkon its military adventure. Saakashvili already felt like a full NATOpartner and thought he could provoke Russia without punishment. Andthe Russians thought it was time to teach him a lesson.
No one in NATO is likely to have even considered hurling themselvesinto the breach for tiny Georgia. The Americans need Russia to helpthem keep Iran in line. With its show of military might Moscow hasreminded the West where part of its oil and gas come from. And it hasshown the countries in the gray zone between East and West -- Georgia,Ukraine and the former Soviet Central Asian states -- that it makes nosense to seek protection from a West that only gives empty promises.
It's true, security guarantees and pledges of solidarity aren't worthmuch if they run counter to the West's own strategic interests. ThePoles know that all too well -- they hoped in vain for help from theirfriends in 1939, the British and the French, when Hitler and Stalininvaded their country.Since peeling away from Georgia in a 1990-1992 war, South Ossetia hasbeen de facto independent. Russians participated in a mixedpeacekeeping force following a ceasefire agreement in 1992. Althoughunder international law the breakaway region of Abkhazia is part ofGeorgia, it is financially backed by Russia. Most Abkhazians holdRussian passports.Russia is in a difficult position. Moscow warned the West againstrecognizing Kosovo's declaration of independence earlier this year,saying that similar declarations among former Soviet satellites wouldresult. The Russian argument that South Ossetia has a right toautonomy, however, was never extended to Chechnya. The West recognizedKosovo over Russian protest. Now the Kremlin's revenge may well be toofficially acknowledge South Ossetia's independence fromThe US takes Georgia's side in the conflict. Americans considerPresident Mikhail Saakashvili a faithful ally, and US militaryadvisors support him given Georgian participation in the Iraq war. USPresident Bush has accused Russia of a "disproportionate" response andUS Ambassador to the UN Zalmay Khalilzad said Russia was following a"campaign of terror." Russia has rejected the accusations.
The UN Security Council could not agree on a position regarding thesituation proposed by Russia Friday. The Russian document urgedGeorgia and South Ossetia to cease fighting immediately. Russiarequested the council's Friday emergency meeting. Since then, debatein the Security Council has degenerated into a tit-for-tat betweenRussia and the United States.Members did not reach an agreement on the text proposed by Russia. TheSecurity Council nevertheless expressed its alarm over the escalationof the conflict. The Russian proposal requested "immediate cessationof violence" and a return to the negotiating table. Georgia, backed upby the US, viewed the proposal as hemming its opportunity to defenditself. So no agreement was reached.But amid all the tragedy, Saakashvili's behavior does have abeneficial element. The Caucasus conflict may now trigger a deeperdebate in the West about how to deal with the states of the formerSoviet Union. It would probably have been better if Europe had beenquicker to bind Georgia and the Ukraine to the European Union. ButBrussels thought that was "premature" while both countries were busytalking about NATO membership.The Russians are on the home stretch. Georgia is destabilized andTbilisi may well soon have a pro-Russian government. The Germans won'tbe playing much of a role in the diplomatic wrangling over the nextfew weeks even if Chancellor Angela Merkel's summit meeting withMedvedev in Sochi on Friday does focus solely on the Georgianquestion. German foreign ministry state secretary Gernot Erlerdefended the meeting by saying Medvedev was the man to talk to onforeign policy affairs. "Medvedev takes the decisions," said Erler,even though he knows that is not the case. Merkel may be travelling toSochi but the man who pulls the strings -- Prime Minister VladimirPutin -- will be sitting 1,800 kilometers north of there, in Moscow.
That is evident not only in Putin's crisis management regardingGeorgia but in all his moves to intervene in foreign policy sinceMedvedev took power. At the end of May, it was Putin who made theimportant trip to France, the current holder of the rotating EUpresidency, not Medvedev, as previously announced. It was Putin whotalked to US President George W. Bush and French President NicolasSarkozy in Beijing.Many in Moscow refer to Medvedev as "mini-Putin" -- and are hangingtheir portrait of Putin back up next to that if Medvedev in theirgovernment offices.

Russian "peacekeepers" in South Ossetia reinforced by 2 companies from Chechnya

Russian "peacekeepers" in South Ossetia reinforced by 2 companies from Chechnya -

Russian Defense Ministry
MOSCOW Aug 11 (Interfax)- The Russian peacekeepers in theGeorgian-Ossetian conflict zone have been reinforced with troop unitsfrom the "East" and "West" battalions stationed in Chechnya.
"The reinforcements sent to the Russian peacekeepers in theGeorgian-Ossetian conflict zone include two companies from the 'West'and 'East' battalions permanently deployed in Chechnya," a RussianDefense ministry spokesman announced Monday.

Kodori Under Abkhaz Control

Kodori Under Abkhaz Control

Civil Georgia, Tbilisi /
12 Aug.'08 / 23:45

Authorities in breakaway Abkhazia said their forces were in fullcontrol of upper Kodori Gorge.
Officials in Tbilisi have confirmed it.However, there are conflicting reports about how the process took place.The Abkhaz side has claimed that its troops took over the area afterfighting with the Georgian forces throughout the day, on August 12.Shota Utiashvili, the Georgian Interior Ministry spokesman, told Civil.Ge that the Georgian forces were withdrawn from the gorge lastnight.
CNN aired brief footage showing an Abkhaz militia taking down the Georgia's national flag from the administrative building in the gorge.Meanwhile, President Saakashvili told a group of foreign journalistson August 12:
"Within a well-prepared plan, several hundred pieces ofthe Russian [military] equipment, Russian airborne troops, commandedby the airborne troops of Russia landed there [in the Kodori Gorge]and expelled and certainly killed part of the population. Wholepopulation from that place is gone. This is classical case of ethniccleansing.
"Upper Kodori gorge was the only part of breakaway Abkhazia underTbilisi's control.

Vladimir Samanov to lead "peace keeping" troops inAbkhazia

Russia's symbolic move: Vladimir Samanov to lead peace keeping troops inAbkhazia
de A.C. HotNews.roMarţi,

12 august 2008

Russian general Vladimir Samanov, known as one of the toughest militarycommanders will take over the lead of the peace keeping troops inAbkhazia, the second separatist republic of Georgia. This strategicmove, announced by ITAR-TASS agency is a symbolic one, experts declare.
Russian peace keeping troops amount to 9,000 military personnel and over300 armed technical units. Up to November 2007 Samanov was a Defenseministry counselor. He was accused by the Human Rights Watchorganization of massacre in Chechnya while he commanded a militarycampaign there.

Georgia Quits CIS

Georgia Quits CIS

Civil Georgia, Tbilisi / 12 Aug.'08

President Saakashvili said Georgia would quit the Commonwealth ofIndependent States (CIS) and officially denounce Russian troops inAbkhazia and South Ossetia as “occupational forces.”
“We have decided to quit the CIS and to say farewell to the SovietUnion,” Saakashvili told a crowd of tens of thousands of people gatheredoutside Parliament. “We call on Ukraine and other members to also quitthe Russian-ruled CIS .”
“We have also decided to rescind the Russian peacekeepers’ mandate andto declare Abkhazia and South Ossetia occupied territories of Georgia,”he added.

Friday 15 August 2008

Saakashvili Says Russia Hit Pipeline; BP Unaware

Saakashvili Says Russia Hit Pipeline; BP Unaware
Civil Georgia, Tbilisi / 12 Aug.'08
Speaking at a news conference for foreign journalists in Tbilisi onAugust 12, President Saakashvili said that the Russian air strikes hitthe BP-operated oil pipeline in Georgia.Earlier this morning the Georgian officials have claimed the Russianwarplanes dropped three bombs in the area through which the Baku-Supsapipeline runs. It was also reported that one bomb hit the pipelinewithout exploding.BP-Azerbaijan, however, said it was unaware of the attack.“All our facilities are intact and we have no such information," Reutersquoted a BP official as saying.---------------------------------------------------------------BP shuts two energy pipelines in Georgia12.08.2008LONDON (AFP) — British energy giant BP said Tuesday that it has closedtwo more oil and gas pipelines in Georgia because of the ongoingconflict with Russia."We have closed two other pipelines in Georgia -- Baku-Supsa and theSouth Caucasus pipeline, which is a gas pipeline," a BP spokesman told AFP.The key Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) pipeline, which BP also operates, wasshut last week after a blast occurred in a pump at a section in easternTurkey.Russia's armed forces on Tuesday denied deliberately targeting thestrategic BTC conduit running through Georgia after Tbilisi claimed ithad been attacked by the Russian air force."The oil pipeline was never a target that needed to be bombed," deputychief of general staff Anatoly Nogovitsyn said in a televised pressconference.He did not explicitly rule out the possibility that the pipeline mighthave been hit accidentally.BP was also looking into the claim. "We're not aware of any attack atall. We have no report at all of an attack," a spokeswoman told AFPearlier on Tuesday.Georgia's security council chairman said that Russian warplanes hadtargeted the BTC pipeline, which is used to transport oil from theCaspian Sea to Turkey's Mediterranean coast, but could not confirm anydamage."Russians bombed the BTC pipeline south of the city of Rustavi," saidAlexander Lomaia. "We don't know yet whether it was damaged. It's thesecond attempt to bomb this pipeline since August 10."BP operates the 1,774-kilometre (1,109-mile) BTC pipeline -- the world'ssecond largest -- that carries oil from Azerbaijan to Western marketsvia the Turkish Mediterranean port of Ceyhan. It is capable oftransporting 1.2 million barrels of crude per day.

Gazeta Wyborcza Georgia: the Russians Behaving Like in Chechnya

Gazeta Wyborcza Georgia: the Russians Behaving Like in Chechnya
Wojciech Jagielski, Gori2008-08-12, ostatnia aktualizacja 2008-08-12 08:18
When French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner arrived at the hospital inGori on Monday afternoon to visit the war victims, he was passed in thedoorway by orderlies carrying a stretcher with yet another corpse.They took it to the hospital's morgue, where there put it besides adozen others, those who had died on Sunday.'On Friday and Saturday they kept bringing the dead and wounded. Twohundred every day. The sound of sirens was deafening', says MerabMakharadze, a surgeon from Tbilisi, who, when the war with Russia inSouth Ossetia broke out, came to Gori as a volunteer. 'On Sunday, thingscalmed down, we took in some 50-60 people. But today, even though it'sonly noon, they've already brought almost a hundred'.On the first day of the war, virtually all patients brought to thehospital were soldiers. The lightly wounded, covered in bandages, inold, often blood-stained uniforms, stroll among the trees in thehospital's orchard.They don't want to talk about the night battles in the South Ossetiancapital of Tskhinvali, where they were beaten first by Russian tanks andaircraft, and then by paratroopers brought from Pskov. Before burstinginto tears, Private Dawid Guguladze managed to say only that he hadnever imagined it would be such a nightmare.Since Saturday, when the fighting in the streets subsided, most of thepatients have been civilians, victims of Russian air raids, but also ofthe first pacification operations carried out by the Russians inGeorgian-dominated villages in South Ossetia. The nine villages, orrather settlements, were inhabited by several thousand people.They didn't leave in the 1990s, when South Ossetia announced a secessionand, supported by Russia, won a war against Georgia. They didn't leavenow, when Georgian troops entered Tskhinvali last Friday to quash theinsubordinate republic's rebellion. The Georgians' initial advances musthave assured them they were safe. When Russia sent troops to SouthOssetia, and combat aircraft before that, it was already too late toflee. The villages are surrounded by Ossetian settlements from thenorth, and when Tskhinvali to the south was taken by the Russians, allevacuation routes to Georgia were cut off.'Some manage to get through, even though, by setting off on the journey,they risk their lives', says doctor Makharadze. 'But not evacuating thewounded from the villages they'd be leaving them to death'.Those who are desperate enough and have enough fuel, set off as soon asthe Russian warplanes leave and the sound of the bombs dropped by themdies away. They expose themselves to the shelling by Russian andOssetian outposts, to aircraft pursuits. 'I'm not sure whether I moresympathise with their plight or admire their courage', says doctorMakharadze.His patients tell him about life in the besieged, shelled and air-raidedvillages. The dwellers hide in the basements, leaving their sheltersonly to bring some food and water and hide before the guns start theircannonade again. It is the rumble of their fire that can be heard duringthe day from the hills around Tskhinvali.Doctor Daridzhan Kakhidze, a friend of Mr Makharadze's, who has alsocome to Gori as a volunteer from the Tbilisi ambulance service, addsthat the most recent wave of patients are victims of Russianpacification operations in the Georgian villages. In South Ossetia, butalso in Gori county, on the Georgian side of the border.'Russian soldiers enter the villages as soon as the warplanes bombingthem have left. They search the houses, check documents, saying they'relooking for guerrillas and spies', Ms Kakhidze says. 'People say theyact exceptionally brutal, like they recently did in Chechnya'.First nearly 40,000 Ossetians fled the province, which has a totalpopulation of 60-70,000, from the advancing Georgians. Now it's theGeorgians, who were few there anyway, who are fleeing from the Russians.translated by Marcin WawrzyńczakŹródło: Gazeta Wyborczahttp://tinyurl.com/5qhdzn

Dutch journalist killed in Russian bombing of Gori

Tuesday, Aug. 12, 2008
Dutch journalist killed in Russian bombing of Gori
The Associated PressTBILISI, Georgia A Dutch television journalist was killed overnight whenRussian warplanes bombed the central Georgian city of Gori.The television news station RTL reported on its Web site that itscameraman Stan Storimans, 39, was killed and correspondent JeroenAkkermans was wounded in the leg in the attack. RTL said at least fivepeople died in the Gori bombing.At least two other journalists have been reported killed previously inthe fighting between Georgian and Russian troops, now in its fifth day.Gori was bombed overnight by Russian forces who have occupied the nearbyGeorgian separatist region of South Ossetia and on Monday advanced intoGeorgia proper. Gori was all but deserted late Monday after mostremaining residents and Georgian soldiers fled.Dutch Ambassador Onno Van Elderenbosch said Storimans was working in amedia center that had been set up on the top floor of Gori's three-storytelevision and radio center. It was not clear whether the buildingitself had been hit.However, Georgian officials say Russian forces have been targetingadministrative buildings. The television center is located 200 meters(yards) from Gori's central administrative building.Gori's university and its post office were on fire Tuesday after thebombings, Georgian officials said.Dutch Foreign Minister Maxime Verhagen, who knew Storimans, summoned theRussian ambassador to his office in The Hague on Tuesday for anexplanation of what happened."My thoughts go out to Mr. Storimans' family, especially his wife andtwo children," Verhagen said in a statement, calling him a "hardworkingprofessional and an exceptionally sympathetic man."Storimans had planned to publish a book this year describing his 20years of reporting from hotspots like Sri Lanka, Congo, Indonesia,Afghanistan, Iraq and the former Yugoslavia, among others.RTL Nieuws, based in Hilversum, Netherlands, is controlled byLuxembourg-based RTL Group SA, Europe's largest private broadcastingcompany, which in turn is owned by German media conglomerate Bertelsmann AG.

Did Russian cyber attacks precede military action?

Did Russian cyber attacks precede military action?
Submitted by stiennon on Tue, 08/12/2008 - 8:46am.
The RBNexploit blog states that the website president.gov.ge was underDDoS attack since Thursday. That site is now hosted out of Atlanta,Georgia (don't you love coincidence?) by Tulip Systems who isprominently displaying an AP story whcih says in part:"The original servers located in the country of Georgia were "floodedand blocked by Russians" over the weekend, Nino Doijashvili, chiefexecutive of Atlanta-based hosting company Tulip Systems Inc., said Monday.The Georgian-born Doijashvili happened to be on vacation in Georgiawhen fighting broke out on Friday. She cold-called the government tooffer her help and transferred president.gov.ge and rustavi2.com, theWeb site of a prominent Georgian TV station, to her company's serversSaturday.Speaking via cell phone from Georgia, Doijashvili said the attacks,traced to Moscow and St. Petersburg, are continuing on the U.S. servers.The president's site was intermittently available midday Monday.Route-tracing performed by the AP confirmed that the sites were hostedat Tulip."See that part about the attacks continuing after the web server wasmoved to Atlanta? Remember my warnings when this broke out? If youhappen to host your web applications on Tulip Systems' servers you maybe suffering from slow response times or even outages. Collateral damagefrom cyber war.Rusisan military surrogates in the form of the criminal Russian BusinessNetwork are engaged in attacks against servers on US soil. This pointshould be brought up as the Group of 8-1 discusses appropriate responsesto Russia's attack on Georgia.Ok, one more point. Thursday? The attacks on the President's web serverstarted *before* the action started in South Ossitia? Was this whole warpre-meditated on the part of Russia? Did they incite Georgia to takeaction against the separatists at a time that was oh so convenientlycoincident with the start of the Olympics in Beijing? I may be sufferingfrom time-zone confusion but when the dust settles Russia is going tohave some explaining to do.1. Was the war with Georgia orchestrated? (I know this is obvious, butdiplomacy seems so far removed from reality I think the point should bestressed.)2. How did the criminals at RBN know to launch attacks when they did?(In other words what is the real connection between RBN and Putin'smachine?)3. Russia has now launched cyber attacks against a web site physicallyhosted in the US. Is that an act of cyber war?While the press focuses on Medvedev's call for a "halt" to the war(which is oddly enough still continuing according to Georgia) attentionshould also be paid to the ongoing cyber war.

IHT: Russia blames the victim

International Herald TribuneWAR WITH GEORGIARussia blames the victimBy Svante E. CornellAugust 12, 2008WASHINGTON:Russia is portraying its war in Georgia as a legitimate response toGeorgia's incursion last week into its breakaway region of SouthOssetia. Many in the West, while condemning the disproportionate natureof Russia's response, are also critical of Georgian President MikheilSaakashvili for his attempts to bring South Ossetia back under Georgianrule, and of the United States for supposedly encouraging Saakashvili'srisk-taking by pushing NATO membership for Georgia.But the truth is that for the past several months, Russia, not Georgia,has been stoking tensions in South Ossetia and another of Georgia'sbreakaway areas, Abkhazia. After NATO held a summit meeting in Bucharestin April - at which Georgia and Ukraine received positive signs ofpotential membership - President Vladimir Putin of Russia signed adecree effectively treating Abkhazia and South Ossetia as parts of theRussian Federation. This was a direct violation of Georgia's territorialintegrity.It came after years of growing Russian efforts to assert control overthese regions, for example by distributing Russian passports to citizensand arranging the appointment of Russians to the territories'governments. Putin, who is now Russia's prime minister, oversaw abuild-up of Russian "peacekeeping" forces in Abkhazia, which was clearlyintended to provoke Georgia into a military response.Yet Georgia showed restraint - in large part because Saakashviliunderstood that military adventurism would harm his NATO prospects.Moscow, in turn, transferred its efforts to South Ossetia, wherepro-Russian rebels carried out attacks on Georgian forces and villages,finally provoking the response that Moscow had sought as a pretext tointervene.Now Moscow has sent out the Black Sea fleet to Georgia's coast andbroadened the war into Abkhazia and Georgia proper, showing thatMoscow's war is not just about South Ossetia. In any case, Moscow's owntreatment of separatism - killing tens of thousands of Chechens over thepast decade - says volumes about its claims that it is just trying toprotect a minority population.This war is about making an example in Georgia, about the consequencespost-Soviet countries will suffer for standing up to Moscow, conductingdemocratic reforms and seeking military and economic ties with the West.No Eurasian country has come so far as Georgia in recent years in termsof democratization and reform.Georgia has the third-largest contingent of forces in Iraq, and beforethis crisis it had pledged to send forces to Afghanistan.If Georgia is allowed to fall, governments across Eurasia will certainlytake note, especially those - such as Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Ukraine- that have built ties with the West and sought closer integration inEuropean institutions, drawing Moscow's ire.Should the United States allow Russia to occupy Georgia or even justdepose the Saakashvili government, the implications for America'sstanding in Eurasia would be dire. Washington would risk losing thesupport of the post-Soviet states of Central Asia that are cooperatingwith the American mission in Afghanistan, along with hopes of westwardexports of more Central Asian energy.Many who might agree with this analysis nonetheless shrug theirshoulders over solutions. Indeed, we have no real military optionsagainst Russia. But we can put together a meaningful comprehensivereaction, attaching real costs to Russia for its policies.America must hit where it hurts: Russia's international prestige, anobsession of Putin's. To begin with, we must do everything possible tosee Russia's membership in the Group of 8 be suspended (something theRepublican presidential hopeful John McCain called for even before thiscrisis).Once the fighting is over, America must step up its campaign for NATOmembership for Georgia and Ukraine. Should European countries reject theidea, America could designate them "major non-NATO allies," along thelines of Israel and Pakistan. This would involve more American militarytrainers in Georgia, intelligence sharing, joint exercises and othersteps, if not a full pledge by Washington to defend the country in caseof attack.Finally, in a measure of fitting symbolism, America must note thatRussia started this war on the opening day of the Olympics, while itplans to hold its own Winter Olympics only a dozen miles from the victimof its aggression. America should seriously consider announcing aboycott of the 2014 Sochi Olympics. We owe our Georgian allies nothing less.Svante E. Cornell is the research director of the Central Asia-CaucasusInstitute at Johns Hopkins University's School of Advanced InternationalStudies.http://www.iht.com/articles/2008/08/12/opinion/edcornell.php

IHT: Russia blames the victim

International Herald TribuneWAR WITH GEORGIARussia blames the victimBy Svante E. CornellAugust 12, 2008WASHINGTON:Russia is portraying its war in Georgia as a legitimate response toGeorgia's incursion last week into its breakaway region of SouthOssetia. Many in the West, while condemning the disproportionate natureof Russia's response, are also critical of Georgian President MikheilSaakashvili for his attempts to bring South Ossetia back under Georgianrule, and of the United States for supposedly encouraging Saakashvili'srisk-taking by pushing NATO membership for Georgia.But the truth is that for the past several months, Russia, not Georgia,has been stoking tensions in South Ossetia and another of Georgia'sbreakaway areas, Abkhazia. After NATO held a summit meeting in Bucharestin April - at which Georgia and Ukraine received positive signs ofpotential membership - President Vladimir Putin of Russia signed adecree effectively treating Abkhazia and South Ossetia as parts of theRussian Federation. This was a direct violation of Georgia's territorialintegrity.It came after years of growing Russian efforts to assert control overthese regions, for example by distributing Russian passports to citizensand arranging the appointment of Russians to the territories'governments. Putin, who is now Russia's prime minister, oversaw abuild-up of Russian "peacekeeping" forces in Abkhazia, which was clearlyintended to provoke Georgia into a military response.Yet Georgia showed restraint - in large part because Saakashviliunderstood that military adventurism would harm his NATO prospects.Moscow, in turn, transferred its efforts to South Ossetia, wherepro-Russian rebels carried out attacks on Georgian forces and villages,finally provoking the response that Moscow had sought as a pretext tointervene.Now Moscow has sent out the Black Sea fleet to Georgia's coast andbroadened the war into Abkhazia and Georgia proper, showing thatMoscow's war is not just about South Ossetia. In any case, Moscow's owntreatment of separatism - killing tens of thousands of Chechens over thepast decade - says volumes about its claims that it is just trying toprotect a minority population.This war is about making an example in Georgia, about the consequencespost-Soviet countries will suffer for standing up to Moscow, conductingdemocratic reforms and seeking military and economic ties with the West.No Eurasian country has come so far as Georgia in recent years in termsof democratization and reform.Georgia has the third-largest contingent of forces in Iraq, and beforethis crisis it had pledged to send forces to Afghanistan.If Georgia is allowed to fall, governments across Eurasia will certainlytake note, especially those - such as Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Ukraine- that have built ties with the West and sought closer integration inEuropean institutions, drawing Moscow's ire.Should the United States allow Russia to occupy Georgia or even justdepose the Saakashvili government, the implications for America'sstanding in Eurasia would be dire. Washington would risk losing thesupport of the post-Soviet states of Central Asia that are cooperatingwith the American mission in Afghanistan, along with hopes of westwardexports of more Central Asian energy.Many who might agree with this analysis nonetheless shrug theirshoulders over solutions. Indeed, we have no real military optionsagainst Russia. But we can put together a meaningful comprehensivereaction, attaching real costs to Russia for its policies.America must hit where it hurts: Russia's international prestige, anobsession of Putin's. To begin with, we must do everything possible tosee Russia's membership in the Group of 8 be suspended (something theRepublican presidential hopeful John McCain called for even before thiscrisis).Once the fighting is over, America must step up its campaign for NATOmembership for Georgia and Ukraine. Should European countries reject theidea, America could designate them "major non-NATO allies," along thelines of Israel and Pakistan. This would involve more American militarytrainers in Georgia, intelligence sharing, joint exercises and othersteps, if not a full pledge by Washington to defend the country in caseof attack.Finally, in a measure of fitting symbolism, America must note thatRussia started this war on the opening day of the Olympics, while itplans to hold its own Winter Olympics only a dozen miles from the victimof its aggression. America should seriously consider announcing aboycott of the 2014 Sochi Olympics. We owe our Georgian allies nothing less.Svante E. Cornell is the research director of the Central Asia-CaucasusInstitute at Johns Hopkins University's School of Advanced InternationalStudies.http://www.iht.com/articles/2008/08/12/opinion/edcornell.php

AFP: Georgia reports attacks as thousands rally

MICHAEL MAINVILLE AND IRAKLI METREVELI TBILISI, GEORGIAAug 12 2008 18:41Georgia said on Tuesday that Russian attacks on the country continueddespite Russia's pledge to halt its military offensive as 100 000people gathered in central Tbilisi in a mass outpouring of patriotism.Having already lost South Ossetia, Georgia withdrew from the lastsliver of Abkhazia controlled by government forces, the Kodori Gorge,and said bombings and troop movements persisted elsewhere."We have left Kodori. There was an evacuation," Interior Ministryspokesperson Shota Utiashvili said, adding that he could provide nofurther details.The secretary of Georgia's National Security Council said that Russiantroops and heavy artillery were also on the move near Abkhazia,heading towards the Georgian region of Mestia.The Georgian Foreign Ministry claimed that Russian bombers had alsoattacked three villages near South Ossetia, with an ambulanceallegedly destroyed in one of them.None of the claims could be confirmed independently.In Tbilisi, about 100 000 people gathered on the main avenue of thecity in front of parliament to hear Georgian President MikheilSaakashvili, face etched with emotion, deliver a rousing speechinsisting "tiny" Georgia would survive.President Dmitry Medvedev earlier on Tuesday said he had ordered ahalt to Russia's onslaught on Georgia, saying its neighbour had beenpunished but could be hit again.A claim Russia had earlier targeted the strategic Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhanpipeline in Georgia, a United States-backed route for oil from theCaspian Sea to Western markets, was denied in Moscow.Before the ceasefire call, the Georgian city of Gori near SouthOssetia came under bombardment, with a Georgian journalist and hisdriver killed when a shell hit their car in the central square, aAgence France-Presse reporter witnessed.A cameraman for Dutch television channel RTL was also killed and acorrespondent for the channel injured, RTL said on its website.Later, Georgian police armed with automatic weapons and grenades movedinto Gori and appeared to be getting ready to patrol the city, thereporter said.Georgia's minister of defence, escorted by special forces, also paid avisit to the hospital there, he said.At his speech in central Tbilisi, Saakashvili announced that Georgiawould quit the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), aMoscow-dominated regional grouping of ex-Soviet countries, and urgedUkraine to follow suit."We have taken a decision: Georgia is quitting the CIS. We urgeUkraine and other countries to follow our decision."He added: "Soviet Union, goodbye forever!"Arriving at the rally, Maia Metreveli (46) said that she had come "tobe with my people"."We would rather die than be under the Russian regime," she said. "Idon't know what is going to happen. No one can predict what theRussians will do but we know they are capable of anything."Fighting between Russia and Georgia broke out last week after theGeorgian army launched an offensive to bring South Ossetia, whichbroke away in the early 1990s, back under government control. --Sapa-AFP

We helped in Iraq - now help us, beg Georgians

From The Times
August 11, 2008
The people of Gori tell our correspondent of betrayal by the West
(David dzinarishvili/REUTERS)

A mother and child in the ravaged Georgian city of Gori, where Russianjets bombed apartment blocksTony HalpinAs a Russian jet bombed fields around his village, Djimali Avago, aGeorgian farmer, asked me: “Why won’t America and Nato help us? Ifthey won’t help us now, why did we help them in Iraq?”A similar sense of betrayal coursed through the conversations of manyGeorgians here yesterday as their troops retreated under shellfire andthe Russian Army pressed forward.Smoke rose as Russian artillery fire exploded less than half a milefrom the bridge marking South Ossetia’s border with Georgia. A groupof Georgian soldiers hastily abandoned their lorry after its wheelswere shot out and ran across the border.Georgian troops looked disheartened as they regrouped around tanklines about 2km from the border. Many said that they had been fightingin Tskhinvali, the capital of South Ossetia, until the early hourswhen they were suddenly ordered to withdraw from the breakaway region.“They told us to come out – I don’t know why – but some of our guysare still out there in the fields,” one soldier told The Times. “Iwant to go back. If we lose South Ossetia now, it won’t be for everbecause we will never surrender our land.”President Saakashvili of Georgia has ordered a complete ceasefire andoffered talks to the Russians. Despite this, the sound of gunfire andshelling could be clearly heard along the border zone last night.Terrified civilians have fled in their thousands, convinced thatRussia will not stop at the border but sweep into Georgia.Gori, normally a bustling city of 50,000 people, is largely desertedafter Russian airstrikes at the weekend. Scores of people wereabandoning their homes and loading possessions into vehicles orcarrying what they could on foot. “There is a lot of panic. Manypeople have left and I am thinking of joining them. My bags arealready packed,” Georgi, a 56-year-old resident of Tirdznisi, said.“We are afraid that the Russians will come here and kill us. Peoplewould not go if we had a strong army but they don’t believe in ourarmy any more.”Iago Jokhadze abandoned his village of Ergneti, close to Tskhinvali,after it was bombed by Russian jets yesterday. Fighting back tears, hesaid: “I have left everything, I don’t even have another shirt. If theRussians stay, then I can never return. We’re afraid of what theRussians can do.”Miriyan Gogolashvili, of Tkviav, said: “The Russians will be heretomorrow. They want to show us and the world how powerful they are.Tomorrow it will be Ukraine and nobody in the West is doing anythingto stop them. Why were our soldiers in Kosovo and Iraq if we don’t getany help from the West now?” he asked.In Tbilisi, the Georgian capital, refugees from the fighting told howRussian helicopters bombed homes in Tshkinvali and neighbouringvillages. Some spent days in basements before emerging to discoverthat their communities had been obliterated. Mzia Sabashvili, who hidfor three days, said: “I know that lots of my neighbours are dead. Ihave no idea who is left.”The Russians paid little heed to those in their way. A vehiclecarrying observers from the Organisation for Security and Cooperationin Europe was shot at by a sniper near Tskhinvali. The bullet crackedthe toughened glass of the passenger window, where a British officerhad been sitting.In Gori, where a statue of Stalin, the city’s most famous son, stillstands in the main square, relatives scoured lists of the wounded putup outside the main hospital. More than 120 people were admittedyesterday in addition to the 456 treated since fighting erupted onFriday. The chief surgeon said that civilians, including a pregnantwoman, had died of their injuries.Scores of soldiers milled around on the road outside. One said thatthey had all been in Tskhinvali but were now preparing to pull out ofGori. “The situation was very bad there but we were ready to stay.Russia is the enemy of the world,” he said.

We helped in Iraq - now help us, beg Georgians

From The Times
August 11, 2008
The people of Gori tell our correspondent of betrayal by the West
(David dzinarishvili/REUTERS)

A mother and child in the ravaged Georgian city of Gori, where Russianjets bombed apartment blocksTony HalpinAs a Russian jet bombed fields around his village, Djimali Avago, aGeorgian farmer, asked me: “Why won’t America and Nato help us? Ifthey won’t help us now, why did we help them in Iraq?”A similar sense of betrayal coursed through the conversations of manyGeorgians here yesterday as their troops retreated under shellfire andthe Russian Army pressed forward.Smoke rose as Russian artillery fire exploded less than half a milefrom the bridge marking South Ossetia’s border with Georgia. A groupof Georgian soldiers hastily abandoned their lorry after its wheelswere shot out and ran across the border.Georgian troops looked disheartened as they regrouped around tanklines about 2km from the border. Many said that they had been fightingin Tskhinvali, the capital of South Ossetia, until the early hourswhen they were suddenly ordered to withdraw from the breakaway region.“They told us to come out – I don’t know why – but some of our guysare still out there in the fields,” one soldier told The Times. “Iwant to go back. If we lose South Ossetia now, it won’t be for everbecause we will never surrender our land.”President Saakashvili of Georgia has ordered a complete ceasefire andoffered talks to the Russians. Despite this, the sound of gunfire andshelling could be clearly heard along the border zone last night.Terrified civilians have fled in their thousands, convinced thatRussia will not stop at the border but sweep into Georgia.Gori, normally a bustling city of 50,000 people, is largely desertedafter Russian airstrikes at the weekend. Scores of people wereabandoning their homes and loading possessions into vehicles orcarrying what they could on foot. “There is a lot of panic. Manypeople have left and I am thinking of joining them. My bags arealready packed,” Georgi, a 56-year-old resident of Tirdznisi, said.“We are afraid that the Russians will come here and kill us. Peoplewould not go if we had a strong army but they don’t believe in ourarmy any more.”Iago Jokhadze abandoned his village of Ergneti, close to Tskhinvali,after it was bombed by Russian jets yesterday. Fighting back tears, hesaid: “I have left everything, I don’t even have another shirt. If theRussians stay, then I can never return. We’re afraid of what theRussians can do.”Miriyan Gogolashvili, of Tkviav, said: “The Russians will be heretomorrow. They want to show us and the world how powerful they are.Tomorrow it will be Ukraine and nobody in the West is doing anythingto stop them. Why were our soldiers in Kosovo and Iraq if we don’t getany help from the West now?” he asked.In Tbilisi, the Georgian capital, refugees from the fighting told howRussian helicopters bombed homes in Tshkinvali and neighbouringvillages. Some spent days in basements before emerging to discoverthat their communities had been obliterated. Mzia Sabashvili, who hidfor three days, said: “I know that lots of my neighbours are dead. Ihave no idea who is left.”The Russians paid little heed to those in their way. A vehiclecarrying observers from the Organisation for Security and Cooperationin Europe was shot at by a sniper near Tskhinvali. The bullet crackedthe toughened glass of the passenger window, where a British officerhad been sitting.In Gori, where a statue of Stalin, the city’s most famous son, stillstands in the main square, relatives scoured lists of the wounded putup outside the main hospital. More than 120 people were admittedyesterday in addition to the 456 treated since fighting erupted onFriday. The chief surgeon said that civilians, including a pregnantwoman, had died of their injuries.Scores of soldiers milled around on the road outside. One said thatthey had all been in Tskhinvali but were now preparing to pull out ofGori. “The situation was very bad there but we were ready to stay.Russia is the enemy of the world,” he said.

Thursday 14 August 2008

Russian jets, unchallenged, sow terror among Georgian troops

Russian jets, unchallenged, sow terror among Georgian troops


By TOM LASSETER
McClatchy Newspapers

TIRDZNISI, Georgia - The Russian fighter jet screamed low to the earthand peeled off so quickly that the bomb wasn't visible until it hitthe ground. The explosion shook everything and sent a shower of debrisflying over the head of a young Georgian soldier.
The soldier, lying against an embankment on the side of the road,shouted in a panicked voice for everyone to stay still. His palms wereflat on the dirt in front of him. "It's Russian MiGs," the soldiersaid, his eyes wide.
For three days, Russian jets and bombers have unleashed a massiveaerial campaign against Georgian forces that, more than anything, dramatically changed the war's direction.Georgia's ground troops couldn't do much against Russian aircraft,whose repeated bombing runs drove them from Tskhinvali on Sunday andchased them along the road toward the town of Gori. In the earlymorning hours Tuesday, it suddenly seemed possible that all thatremained of the war was for the Russians to brush past Gori intoTbilisi, Georgia's capital.
At first, news of Russia's aerial attacks came in fragments. Anairfield was hit, a radar station demolished. But by Monday, as bombsfell among the withdrawing Georgian forces, it was only too clear whatthe Russians had been up to.
The early strikes had made it impossible for Georgians, who in thewar's first day had shot down four Russian aircraft, to mount aneffective response. Now Russian jets could dominate the skies.Col. Gen. Anatoly Nagovitsin, the deputy head of the Russian military's general staff, put it bluntly: "I can report on Russiansupremacy in the airspace. Georgian aircraft stopped flying.
"Outside Tskhinvali, Georgian soldiers huddled beneath trees andbridges, trying to stay out of the line of sight of passing Russianjets. In addition to military trucks, troops were being moved aroundin civilian buses and vans. In Gori, soldiers worked out of auniversity building.They had to hide; there was no answer to the Su-25 fighter jets, TU-22bombers and others streaking nearby, looking for prey.
"We have good artillery, but not good antiaircraft systems," said Sgt.Ucha Chulukhadze, a Georgian soldier who was standing in a smallshelter on the side of the road. To speak with a reporter, he andother soldiers insisted on walking across the street, where there wasshade and they'd be less visible.
The soldiers looked tired and unsure what would happen next."If no one stops them" - the Russians - "then they will do worse herethan what they did in Chechnya," said Eldar Durglishnti, a reservistwho had been called up for the fighting.A group of Georgian soldiers who were standing next to a truck downthe road, its tires flat, heard the boom of an airstrike in thedistance and scrambled to take cover.
"It's coming again," one of them hollered, looking at the sky.Later in the afternoon, a Georgian sergeant was sitting on a curbsidein Gori, recounting what he had seen Sunday in Tskhinvali before hisunit retreated. Moving his hand through the air like a plane, hemimicked the sound of bombs falling."There people were dying," said the soldier, who gave only his firstname, Dato. "They dropped bombs everywhere ... they destroyed us.
"A group of people had gathered at the hospital across the street, manyof them female soldiers, to check the lists of wounded and dead postedon a wall. Tracing the names with their fingers, the women spoke inlow voices.An ambulance doctor, Levan Makashvili, was reading a newspaper in thehospital's parking lot and trying to keep his mind off the war for afew moments.
The aftermath of the bombings, he said, was terrible."The ones with head wounds," he said in a matter-of-fact tone, "theyfrequently die."

Russia tightens the noose

The Independent
By Shaun Walker and Kim Sengupta in Tbilisi and Anne Penketh
Tuesday, 12 August 2008


Russian troops invaded Georgia proper yesterday after building uptheir military presence in two breakaway regions of the pro-Westernstate, prompting the Georgian President to accuse Russia of attemptingthe "cold-blooded, pre-meditated murder" of his country.

Russian military columns were said to have gone forward from Abkhazia,where they have intervened in favour of separatist forces, to capturethe towns of Zugdidi and Senaki, which are inside Georgia itself.

The developments contradicted statements by the Russian President, andmilitary leadership, that Russian forces would confine their war aimsto South Ossetia.As the conflict escalated, Georgia's President, Mikheil Saakashvili,appealed for international intervention to prevent what he claimed wasin effect the annexation of Georgia by Russia. He appeared at thepresidential palace in the capital, Tbilisi, to tell reporters:

"It isso clear what is happening. We are in the process of invasion,occupation and annihilation of an independent democratic country. Weare in the process of the destruction of world order as it wasestablished after the end of the Cold War.

"But in defiance of a chorus of international condemnation, Russianforces thrust deeper inside the former Soviet republic, seizingstrategic positions in a signal that Moscow intended to hold its gainsin the five-day-old war in defiance of international appeals for aceasefire, and was also prepared for escalating confrontation with theUnited States.In a statement last night President George Bush said: "I am deeplyconcerned by reports that Russian troops have moved beyond the zone ofconflict, attacked the Georgian town of Gori, and are threatening theGeorgian capital Tblisi.

"He cited evidence suggesting that Russian forces may soon beginbombing the civilian airport in the capital city."If these reports are accurate, these Russian actions would representa dramatic and brutal escalation of the conflict in Georgia," Mr Bushadded. He said the actions "would be inconsistent with assurances thatwe have received from Russia that its objectives were limited" torestoring peace in separatist pro-Russian areas. Witnesses confirmedclaims that the Georgian Interior Ministry in Zugdidi was in Russianhands. The Russian Defence Ministry, meanwhile, justified theoperation in Senaki saying it was aimed at preventing Georgian forcesfrom regrouping to carry out new attacks on South Ossetia, whereGeorgian forces launched their assault on Thursday night.


A Russian fleet is already positioned off Poti, a key trading port forGeorgia, and the deployment put the port within range of Russian gunson the landside. At the same time, Georgian forces to the west of Abkhazia were given an ultimatum by Russian commanders to disarm orface military action. The deputy foreign minister of the separatistAbkhaz government told The Independent:

"All the Russian troops whoarrived by ship have crossed over to Zugdidi."Last night, the Georgian government claimed that Russian forces hadalso captured Gori, a city on the route from South Ossetia, the sceneof fierce fighting, to Tbilisi. Alexander Lomaia, the secretarygeneral of the Georgian security council, announced: "They havecaptured Gori." However, soon afterwards an adviser to the governmentsaid that was not the case and a resident, Shota Khodzhashvili,confirmed: "The city is deserted but there are no Russians here.

"Mr Saakashvili had earlier described Gori, 45 miles from Tbilisi, asthe gateway to the capital as he repeated claims that the aim of theRussian military operation was to topple his government. Asked whetherhe feared the Kremlin intended to annex permanently the restive regionof South Ossetia, Mr Saakashvili said: "It's not South Ossetia only,but the whole of Georgia."

As Russia continued to pour armour into Abkhazia and South Ossetia, MrSaakashvili said that the invasion must have been planned in advance.A US official levelled a similar accusation against the Russians. USdeputy assistant secretary of state Matt Bryza said after he arrivedin Tbilisi to join officials attempting to broker a ceasefire: "Weheard statements saying that the Russian railroad troops that enteredAbkhazia a couple of months ago were there for a humanitarian mission.Now we know the truth ... these forces were there ... to aid a Russianinvasion.

"The conflict intensified as Condoleezza Rice, the US Secretary ofState, and colleagues from the Group of Seven leading industrialised nations held emergency talks on their call for a negotiated end to theconflict.Mr Saakashvili has accepted the conditions of an EU-designed peaceplan calling for an immediate ceasefire, medical and humanitarian aidfor victims of the violence and the controlled withdrawal of forcesfrom both sides. President Nicolas Sarkozy of France, who has framedthe plan, is due in Tbilisi and Moscow today.


According to diplomats, however, Russia has rejected pulling back itsforces insisting that would put the minorities in South Ossetia and Abkhazia in danger from Georgian retribution. Moscow backed this up bysending more troops and armour into Abkhazia. The West appearsunwilling to sacrifice its relations with Russia in favour of Georgia.A statement last night from the Georgian Embassy in London said:

Russian actions in Georgia "have nothing to do with the enforcement ofpeace" and are a "pre-planned strategy aimed at conquering Georgia".

Another battle in the 1,000 year Russia-Georgia grudge match

Another battle in the 1,000 year Russia-Georgia grudge match


From The Times
August 12, 2008

Retaking Ossetia is just one part of Russia's campaign to reassertdominance over the Caucasus - and defy America
Simon Sebag Montefiore


The Russian tank columns rumbling into Georgia reveal the anger of atiger finally swatting the mouse that has teased it for years. SouthOssetia may seem as distant, trivial and complicated as the19th-century Schleswig-Holstein question but Russia's fury is about much more than the Ossetians. The Caucasus matters greatly to theRussians for all sorts of reasons, none greater than the fact that itnow also matters to us.The troubles in Georgia are not the equivalent of an assassinatedarchduke in Sarajevo. But historians may well point to this littlewar, beside the spectacular Olympic launch of resurgent China, as thestart of the twilight of America's sole world hegemony. If the newGreat Game is for the oil of the Caucasus and Central Asia, the Westmay be in the process of losing it.

I've been visiting Georgia since the fall of the Soviet Empire in1991. I've known all three Georgian presidents since independence, andwitnessed the wars and revolutions of the Caucasian tinderbox. In 1991the chief of the Georgian partisans in the first Ossetian war, adentist turned warlord, drove me up to villages around Tskhinvali,highlands of lusciously green beauty, where a vicious war betweenGeorgian and Ossetian farmers was being waged with the ferocity ofintimate neighbours, using comically armoured tractors instead oftanks.My Georgian hosts leant their guns against a tree and took me to anopen-air feast at a table stacked with delicacies in honour of a localboy killed that day. During the long drunken banquet I asked where theboy was buried. “He hasn't been buried,” replied my host, “he's underyour feet.” Paling, I looked and there he lay, stretched out under thetable, cradled with bouquets of flowers.


To understand this week's events, we must travel back a thousandyears: long before Russia existed, Georgia was a Christian-warriorkingdom. The Caucasus was the natural borderland of the three greatempires of the Near East: the battlefield between Orthodox Russia, theIslamic Ottomans and Persians. In 1783 the embattled King Eralke IIwas forced to claim the protection of Prince Potemkin, Catherine theGreat's partner-in-power. Between 1801 and 1810 Russia swallowed thelast Georgian principalities. In 1918 Georgia enjoyed independence forthree years before Stalin seized it back for Moscow.

No one understood its ethnic complexity and strategic significancelike Stalin, that Georgian romantic turned Russian imperialist, whohad been born in Gori, the town that has been overrun by Russianforces and where a marble temple now stands over the hut where he wasborn. The Ossetians who straddled the border had early sought Russianalliance, earning Georgian disdain. Hence Stalin was accused by hisenemies of being an Ossetian: his father was of Ossetian descent,though long since Georgianised. Stalin drew the borders of the Sovietrepublics to ensure Georgia contained autonomous ethnic entities,South Ossetia, Abkhazia and Adzharia, through which Moscow could keepGeorgia in order.


When that proud, cocky bantam, Georgia, became independent in 1991,the Russian double-headed eagle was humiliated. Ever since, Russianinterference and skulduggery has bedevilled Georgia. Russia encouragedsouthern Ossetia to establish a statelet within Georgia, whose insanefirst President, Zviad Gamsakhurdia, had inflamed ethnic tensions. AsOssetians fought Georgians who themselves rebelled againstGamsakhurdia, I sat in his office: he was a Shakespearean scholar andquoted King Lear to me.

Gamsakhurdia was either murdered or committed suicide. In 1993, hissuccessor Eduard Shevardnadze, the former Soviet Foreign Minister andPolitburo member, lost Abkhazia in another bloody Russian-orchestratedwar. But Shevardnadze won the peace. Georgia, which had longed to bepart of Europe, embraced Western democracy and US friendship. Yet Shevardnadze recognised the limits of Georgian defiance, once tellingme as we flew in 1993 in his plane to make peace with the Kremlin:“The destiny of Russia is reflected in the Caucasus like the rays ofthe sun are reflected in a drop of water.”

Old, autocratic Shevardnadze was toppled in the Rose Revolution of2003 by an energetic and decent if impulsive US-educated lawyer,Mikhail Saakashvili, who hoped to escape Moscow for ever by joiningthe EU and Nato - as did Russia's huge neighbour, Ukraine. Thisprospect of encirclement by triumphant America infuriated Russia.Imagine if newly independent Wales cockily joined the Warsaw Pact.


Russia is no longer the spineless giant of the Nineties: VladimirPutin's musclebound, oil-fuelled authoritarian regime has aggressivelyreinvigorated Russia. He had already shown his ruthless determinationto master the Caucasus by crushing Chechnya. Nato in Georgia wouldhave made that meaningless. The Kremlin has used its clients, Abkhaziaand Ossetia, as Trojan Horses to ruin Tbilisi's independence -recently raising the tension by offering Russian passports to allOssetians and testing Georgian resolve with cross-border skirmishing:the trap of a practised imperial power.Georgia is not guiltless: most Georgians I know care little aboutOssetia even though it is part of sovereign Georgia. But in order tojoin Nato, President Saakashvili wanted to settle Georgia'sinstability by reclaiming Ossetia and Abkhazia. By seizing Tskhinvali,he took one hell of a gamble that Russia wouldn't intervene. Georgiais paying a high price for this. To finish this vicious circle,Russian attacks show how badly Georgia needs EU/Nato protection, yetGeorgia will never get it while embroiled in fighting.

The retaking of Ossetia is a minor part of the Russian campaign. Moresignificant is the attack on Georgia proper, which reasserts Russia'shegemony over the Caucasus, assuages the humiliations of the past 20years, subverts Georgian democracy - and defies and defangs Americansuperpowerdom. The swaggering arrival of Vladimir Putin, now the PrimeMinister, across the border, macho in his tight jeans and whiteleather jacket, shows he, not President Medvedev, remains Russia'sparamount leader.

This war is really a celebration of ferocious force in the realm ofinternational power, a dangerous precedent. The West must protest withunified resolve; Russia both despises Western hypocrisy and cravesWestern approval. Georgian democracy and sovereignty matter. So do ouroil supplies: the West built a pipeline to bring oil from Azerbaijanand Central Asian across Georgia to Turkey, free of Russianinterference.


Russia's clumsy ferocity could ignite a Caucasian tinderbox that evenMoscow cannot extinguish. But faced with Western outrage, the Kremlinmight toss Stalin's words back at President Bush: “How many divisionshas the Pope?” None: Washington and London are not sending the 101stAirborne or the SAS.

Russia, which appears to be pushing its tanks into Georgia tooverthrow its democratically elected president, has demonstratedgleefully the limits of US power. The Empire has struck back andshaken the order of the world.

Simon Sebag Montefiore is the author of Young Stalin

Russian forces shell deserted city of Gori, hours before ceasefire

Russian forces shell deserted city of Gori, hours before ceasefire

August 12, 2008
Tony Halpin in Gori
Russian forces shelled the deserted city of Gori today, hours before President Dmitri Medvedev ordered a halt to military operationsagainst Georgia.
In the first confirmation that Russian troops had moved to theoutskirts of the city, as fragmentation shells landed around Gori'smain square, dominated by a statue of Joseph Stalin.One shell killed a Dutch television cameraman, Stan Storimans, andwounded his correspondent colleague Jeroen Akkermans after it landednext to Gori's media centre, where international journalists had beenworking throughout the crisis. The building's windows had shatteredand shrapnel peppered walls as much as 10 feet up.An eyewitness told The Times that at least four local residents hadalso been killed in blasts. Zhura Akopashvili said that the shells hadfallen in rapid succession, scattering metal fragments into cars andbuildings.
Broken glass carpeted the street after the explosions damagedbuildings around the square. The only food store that had operated inthe city throughout the conflict was also severely damaged."There was a noise and then suddenly explosions. We didn't hear anyaircraft, they just came from nowhere, the poor journalists neverstood a chance," Mr Akopashvili said, pointing to the spot near thefoodstore where the TV crew had been hit.The Times was shown a fragment of what appeared to be a Grad missilethat had struck an apartment building just behind the main square.
Zhuzhuna Merabishvili stood in shock next to the casing as she watchedher home being consumed by a fire that raged through the building."I was inside with my son when it hit. There was a huge noise and wewere thrown to the floor," she said sobbing, her left arm shakinguncontrollably. "We were the only ones left in the building, everyoneelse had gone. I have only one home so where should I go? Now I don'teven have that."Colonel-General Anatoly Nogovitsyn, deputy head of the General Staffin Moscow, denied that Russian forces had attacked Gori, which wasabandoned in a panic yesterday by Georgian troops and tanks.
The streets of this normally thriving city of 50,000 were eerilyquiet. Shops are locked up and apartment buildings deserted becausevirtually the whole population has left.The few remaining residents said that Russian jets had bombed thehillsides overlooking the city earlier in the day. Plumes of smokecould be seen rising from the hills as The Times approached Gori.
After President Medvedev's announcement of a halt to operations,however, The Times saw three attack helicopters rising suddenly frombehind a hillside deep into Georgia about halfway along the road fromGori to Tbilisi.In Tbilisi, long queues formed at petrol stations as anxious Georgiansfilled their cars in anticipation of having to flee a Russian advance.
Many stores were also shut and the government ordered banks to closefor three days to prevent a run on the Georgian currency.This afternoon, as many as 50,000 Georgians joined a demonstration ofsupport for Mr Saakashvili, who addressed the gathering as red andwhite Georgian flags fluttered defiantly all over Tbilisi's centralRustaveli Avenue.

Defiant Georgians: 'This is an attack on democracy'

Matthew Collin in Tbilisi and Jonathan Steele

The Guardian,Monday August 11 2008

Gori, the Georgian town close to the border with South Ossetia, waslargely deserted last night after thousands of residents fled fromRussian air attack."The town and many nearby villages are too dangerous. [People] aresleeping in the open," Saba Tsitsikashvili, editor of Kartlis Khma, alocal paper, said in a phone interview. "There are also many woundedin the villages. They need help. No one knows how many are dead."Gori is the Georgian army's main staging post on the way to and fromthe frontline. Russian bombers had been heard every night since thecrisis escalated, Tsitsikashvili said, and were in the air again lastnight, in spite of a ceasefire on the Georgian side, he added.
In Tibilisi, the Georgian capital, people were angry at what they sawas a Russian invasion aimed at undermining the country's sovereigntyand bringing it to heel."What is happening is not because of the separatist regions, whichhave been a headache for Georgia for over a decade now, but because ofdemocracy in Georgia," said Giorgi, a 30-year-old lawyer. "Russiahates democracy, it's always been an authoritarian state and alwayswill be. This Russian aggression is a fight against democracy, and theworld must defend democracy."
"Russia has always wanted to see Georgia on its knees, but it willnever achieve that," vowed Emzari, a 45-year-old technician. "I hopethat Russia will retreat. I hope it will break its neck here in theCaucasus."Hundreds gathered for a second day of anti-Russian protests in thecentral Rose Revolution Square after a text-message campaign. "Let'sstand together against Russian aggression and occupation, and cheerour troops!" the message read.
Many people were also disillusioned by what they considered the feeblereaction of the west - particularly the United States, Georgia's maininternational ally. Many complained that Georgia had sent 2,000 troopsto fight in Iraq, but when Georgia came under attack, Washington couldonly offer words in return.
"We've been hearing all these years that we've got strong and powerfulfriends across the ocean but it turned out these stories were just abluff," said unemployed Valiko, 57.
"We may be stupid, we may have made mistakes, but will the US andEurope really let Russia get away with attacking another country?"demanded 26-year-old student Vakhtang.

Stories of survival and destruction from residents of the Georgian town hit by Russian jets

Stories of survival and destruction from residents of the Georgian town hit by Russian jets

Luke Harding in Gori

The Guardian,Tuesday August 12 2008

Local residents pass by a damaged building in Gori, Georgia.Photograph:

Sergei Grits/APThere wasn't much left of Kostia Asershvili's living room. Hischandelier sat in the middle of a glass-strewn carpet. The windows inthe children's bedroom had been blown out.Next door had fared worse. Kostia's neighbour was killed when a bomblanded on his roof.Across the road, other blocks of flats in the town of Gori hadsuffered the same fate: scorched and twisted metal lay in thecourtyard, surrounded by clothes, bricks, pillow feathers - and thesmell of burnt flesh.
"I was lucky. I got my children out 15 minutes before the bombs fell,"Kostia said, showing off his wonky door lintels and broken windows. Headded: "I don't know who's to blame for this war. The only thing Iknow is that it isn't me."Ostensibly, the Russian jets that bombed Kostia's house were aimingfor a Georgian tank base a couple of miles away. The bombs did notreach their target.Perhaps they weren't meant to. Instead, they landed on a residentialdistrict of Gori - the town that has borne the brunt of Russia'svengeful bombardment of Georgia after President Mikhail Saakashvili'sunsuccessful attempt last week to seize back the breakaway province ofSouth Ossetia.
Georgian tanks rolled into the mountainous enclave, 14 miles away fromGori, last Thursday; on Sunday they withdrew from South Ossetia'scapital, Tskhinvali. Despite having turfed the Georgians out, Russiatoday continued to bomb targets beyond the conflict zone all acrossGeorgia.With the tiny country's air defences flattened, the Russian air forcecan now fly insouciantly across Georgian airspace. Georgia yesterdaysaid Russian planes had launched 50 attacks overnight - a claim Moscowdenies.
Two Russian fighters did lob bombs on to a disused, communist-eraaerodrome near the border with Azerbaijan; others hit a radar stationin the capital Tbilisi, sending panic-stricken residents fleeing fromtheir beds at dawn, and crippling the international airport."It was 5am. We saw the planes loop over the forest. They thenreleased their rockets. There was a huge cloud of dust," FridonAkobia, a 41-year-old border guard on the river crossing into Georgia,said. He added: "We didn't know where the bombers were going to hit."Russia's indiscriminate bombing strategy appears to have no realmilitary objective. Instead it looks like a vindictive post-factoexercise in collective punishment.
In Gori, residents returned to examine their homes, wrecked in theweekend bombing. The five-story block across the road from Kostia'swas a blackened ruin: the upper stories had disappeared, its neat vinetrellis staved in as if by a giant fist."We lived on the fifth floor. We fled just before the attack started,"Nana Tetsladzi, 35, said. Her husband, Giorgy, 35, got out too. ButNana's pregnant neighbour Marca, who lived below on the second floor,wasn't quick enough."She and her husband were both killed. I don't know what happened totheir seven-year-old boy," she said. "He may be in hospital." In thecourtyard were the mangled remains of Marca's white car. She had beentrying to flee in it when the Russians struck.Nana opened up her garage to show off her surviving possessions: adust-covered television set, blankets, and a rack of glass jars. "Thisis all we have left," she said, tearfully.
Most inhabitants of Gori have fled. Some clearly left in a hurry: downone sidestreet, someone had left a generously sized red bra hanging inthe front garden. A few bakeries remained open today, churning outloaves of delicious round bread. Most of the town is undamaged; itsshops and bombed market are shut.In the afternoon a fleet of ambulances drove past Gori's main square -adorned with a statue of Stalin, who was born here. Among those whostayed, the mood was anger, directed not just at neighbouring Russiabut also at the west, which, they said, had failed spectacularly tohelp Georgia in its moment of need.
"If Europe and the US don't stop Russia, in 20 years time you'll see anew wall going up in Berlin," Paata Aspanadze - who had driven to Gorito visit his elderly mother - warned. "Russia wants to get back itsempire. Today they kill us; tomorrow they will kill you."Paata did not agree that Saakashvili's attempt to reclaim SouthOssetia was, as many have suggested, a reckless and ill-thought-outgamble bound to provoke Russia's wrath. Instead, he painted Georgia'sconflict with Russia as nothing less than a struggle for survival."If we say to Russia, 'OK, have two bits of Georgia,' then Georgia'sindependence will be finished,' he said.
Others decried Russia's hypocrisy, for encouraging separatism inGeorgia while ruthlessly crushing it in next-door Chechnya, the sceneof two brutal Kremlin wars."Russia is completely to blame. Georgia is an independent, sovereigncountry. They are just trying to grab our land," Paata's brother Nukrisaid during a family reunion over fizzy Georgian juice at his mother'supstairs flat."Why is the world not doing anything? Russia is using the same excuse,of protecting its citizens, that Hitler used in 1939."It is so far not yet clear what impact this crisis will have on thepolitical fortunes of Saakashviili, Georgia's pro-US leader. Moscowhas demanded that he step down, accusing him of genocide and othercrimes.Nobody doubts that the conflict has set back Georgia's attempt to joinNato by years, if not decades. At the same time, Georgia is moreisolated than ever before. The country's international airport isscarcely operational: to reach Georgia, you have to fly via Armenia orBaku, the capital of Azerbaijan. A bumpy, if picturesque, 10-hour carjourney then threads through wine-growing eastern Georgia, pasthorse-drawn carts transporting melons through fields of yellowsunflowers.
But the abiding emotion in Georgia at the moment is fear – fear ofwhere the Russian jets may strike on their next languid bombing run."People are scared," said Lika Teravze, a parliamentary researcher inTbilisi. "Russian bombers woke us at 4.50am this morning. We ran outinto the street to see what the noise was. We were looking into thesky wondering where the bombs would fall."

Russia opens new front, drives deeper into Georgia

Russia opens new front, drives deeper into Georgia

By CHRISTOPHER TORCHIA and DAVID NOWAK,
Associated Press Writers 17minutes ago

ZUGDIDI, Georgia - Russian tanks roared deep into Georgia on Monday, launching a new western front in the conflict, and Russian planesstaged air raids that sent people screaming and fleeing for cover insome towns.
The escalating warfare brought sharp words from President Bush, whopressed Moscow to accept an immediate cease-fire and pull its troopsout to avert a "dramatic and brutal escalation" of violence in theformer Soviet republic.Russian forces for the first time moved well outside the two restive,pro-Russian provinces claimed by Georgia that lie at the heart of thedispute. An Associated Press reporter saw Russian troops in control ofgovernment buildings in this town just miles from the frontier andRussian troops were reported in nearby Senaki.
Georgia's president said his country had been sliced in half with thecapture of a critical highway crossroads near the central city ofGori, and Russian warplanes launched new air raids across the country.The Russian Defense Ministry, through news agencies, denied it hadcaptured Gori and also denied any intentions to advance on theGeorgian capital of Tbilisi.The western assault expanded the days-old war beyond the centralbreakaway region of South Ossetia, where a crackdown by Georgia lastweek drew a military response from Russia.
While most Georgian forces were still busy fighting there, Russiantroops opened the western attack by invading from a second separatistprovince, Abkhazia, that occupies Georgia's coastal northwest arm.Russian forces moved into Senaki, 20 miles inland from the Black Sea,and seized police stations in Zugdidi, just outside the southernfringe of Abkhazia. Abkhazian allies took control of the nearbyvillage of Kurga, according to witnesses and Georgian officials.
U.N. officials B. Lynn Pascoe and Edmond Mulet in New York, speakingat an emergency Security Council meeting asked for by Georgia, alsoconfirmed that Russian troops have driven well beyond South Ossetiaand Abkhazia, U.N. diplomats said on condition of anonymity because itwas a closed session. They said Russian airborne troops were notmeeting any resistance while taking control of Georgia's Senaki army base.
"A full military invasion of Georgia is going on," Georgian AmbassadorIrakli Alasania told reporters later. "Now I think Security Councilhas to act."France also circulated a draft resolution calling for the "cessationof hostilities, and the complete withdrawal of Russian and Georgianforces" to prior positions. The council is expected to take up thedraft proposal Tuesday.The Georgian president, Mikhail Saakashvili, told CNN late Monday thatRussian forces were cleansing Abkhazia of ethnic Georgians."I directly accuse Russia of ethnic cleansing," he said. At the U.N.on Friday, each side accused the other of ethnic cleansing.
By late Monday, Russian news agencies, citing the Defense Ministry,said troops had left Senaki "after liquidating the danger," but didnot give details.Early Tuesday, Russia's Interfax news agency reported that separatisttroops in Abkhazia started an operation to push Georgian forces out ofthe northern Kodori Gorge, the only area of Abkhazia still underGeorgian control. Interfax reported that Abkhazia defense headquarterssaid the offensive began about 2 a.m.
The new Russia assault came despite a claim earlier in the day by atop Russian general that Russia had no plans to enter undisputedGeorgian territory.Saakashvili earlier told a national security meeting Russia had alsotaken central Gori, which its on Georgia's only east-west highway,cutting off the eastern half of the nation from the western Black Seacoast.But the news agency Interfax cited a Russian Defense Ministry officialas denying Gori was captured. Attempts to reach Gori residents bytelephone late Monday did not go through.
Fighting also raged Monday around Tskhinvali, the capital of theseparatist province of South Ossetia.Even as Saakashvili signed a cease-fire pledge Monday with Europeanmediators, Russia flexed its military muscle and appeared determinedto subdue the small U.S. ally, which has been pressing for NATOmembership."The bombs that are falling on us, they have an inscription on them:This is for NATO. This is for the U.S.," Saakashvili told CNN.Russia's massive and multi-pronged offensive has drawn wide criticismfrom the West, but Russia has rejected calls for a cease-fire and saidit was acted to protect its citizens. Most residents of the separatistregions have Russian passports.In Zugdidi, an AP reporter saw five or six Russian soldiers postedoutside an Interior Ministry building. Several tanks and other armoredvehicles were moving through the town but the streets were nearlydeserted. Shops, restaurants and banks were shut down.
In the city of Gori, an AP reporter heard artillery fire and Georgian soldiers warned locals to get out because Russian tanks wereapproaching. Hundreds of terrified residents fled toward Tbilisi, manytrying to flag down passing cars.An AP film crew saw Georgian tanks and military vehicles speedingalong the road from Gori to Tbilisi. Firing began and people ran forcover. Cars could be seen in flames along the side of the road.Both provinces of South Ossetia and Abkhazia have run their ownaffairs without international recognition since fighting to split fromGeorgia in the early 1990, and both have close ties with Moscow.
When Georgia began its offensive to regain control over South Ossetia,the Russian response was swift and overpowering — thousands of troopsand tanks poured in.Georgia had pledged a cease-fire, but it rang hollow Monday. An APreporter saw a small group of Georgian fighters open fire on a columnof Russian and Ossetian military vehicles outside Tskhinvali,triggering a 30-minute battle. The Russians later said all theGeorgians were killed.Another AP reporter was in the village of Tkviavi, 7 1/2 miles southof Tskhinvali inside undisputed Georgian territory, when a bomb from aRussian warplane struck a house. The walls of neighboring buildingsfell as screaming residents ran for cover. Eighteen people were wounded.
Hundreds of Georgian troops headed north Monday along the road towardTskhinvali, pocked with tank regiments creeping up the highway intoSouth Ossetia.In a statement in the Rose Garden, Bush said there was an apparentattempt by Russia to unseat the pro-Western Saakashvili. He saidfurther Russian action would conflict with Russian assurance itsactions were meant to restore peace in the pro-Russian separatist areas.Bush and other Western leaders have also complained that Russianwarplanes — buzzing over Georgia since Friday — have bombed Georgianoil sites and factories far from the conflict zone.
The world's seven largest economic powers urged Russia to accept animmediate cease-fire agree to international mediation.Putin criticized the United States for viewing Georgia as the victiminstead of the aggressor, and for airlifting Georgian troops back homefrom Iraq on Sunday."Of course, Saddam Hussein ought to have been hanged for destroying several Shiite villages," Putin said in Moscow. "And the incumbentGeorgian leaders who razed ten Ossetian villages at once, who ranelderly people and children with tanks, who burned civilian alive intheir sheds — these leaders must be taken under protection.
"The U.S. military was informing Russia about the flights from Iraq toavoid mishaps, one military official said Monday on condition ofanonymity because he was not authorized to speak about the subject onthe record.A Defense Department spokesman said the U.S. expected to have allGeorgian troops out of Iraq by day's end.
Pentagon officials said Monday that U.S. military was assessing thefighting every day to determine whether to pull the fewer than 100remaining American trainers out of the country.EU envoys were headed to Moscow to try to persuade Russia to accept acease-fire. French President Nicolas Sarkozy said he will meet Tuesdayin Moscow with President Dmitri Medvedev and then travel to Tbilisifor a meeting with Saakashvili.
Saakashvili voiced concern Russia's true goal was to undermine hispro-Western government. "It's all about the independence and democracyof Georgia," he said.The Georgian president said Russia had sent 20,000 troops and 500tanks into Georgia. He said Russian warplanes were bombing roads andbridges, destroying radar systems and targeting Tbilisi's civilianairport. One Russian bombing raid struck the Tbilisi airport area onlya half-hour before EU envoys arrived, he said.Another hit near key Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline, which carriesCaspian crude to the West. No supply interruptions have been reported.At least 9,000 Russian troops and 350 armored vehicles were inAbkhazia, according to a Russian military commander.
Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Grigory Karasin said more than 2,000people have been killed in South Ossetia since Friday, most of themOssetians with Russian passports. The figures could not beindependently confirmed, but refugees who fled Tskhinvali over theweekend said hundreds had been killed.Many found shelter in the Russian province of North Ossetia."The Georgians burned all of our homes," said one elderly woman, asshe sat on a bench under a tree with three other white-hairedsurvivors. "The Georgians say it is their land. Where is our land, then?"___
Associated Press writers Chris Torchia reported from Zugdidi, Georgia;Misha Dzhindzhikhashvili from Tbilisi, Georgia; David Nowak from Gori,Georgia; Douglas Birch from Vladikavkaz, Russia; Jim Heintz, VladimirIsachenkov and Lynn Berry from Moscow; and Pauline Jelinek fromWashington and John Heilprin from the U.N.

"Chechen terrorists" attached to Russian troops in Georgia

11.08.2008

Chechens attached to Russian troops in Georgia Radio Ekho Moskvy, referring to a representative of the Russian Ministryof Defence reports that in the structure of armed forces attached to thecontingent of Russian peacemakers in Georgia’s troubled areas there arealso two companies of the special-task battalions Zapad (West) andVostok (East), which are constantly deployed in Russia’s ChechenRepublic. Radio notes that news agency ITAR-TASS has confirmed thisreport. Zapad and Vostok battalions are commanded by the MainIntelligence Directorate (abbreviation: GRU) of the Russian General Staff.
The Vostok and Zapad battalions, which are part of the 42nd MotorizedRifle Division that is permanently deployed in Chechnya, have been incharge of operations in the eastern and western parts of the republic,respectively. In June, Leutenant-General Vladimir Shamanov, head of theRussian Armed Forces combat training directorate said the battalions“perform tasks not only in the framework of the Joint Group of Forces inthe North Caucasus, but also peacekeeping tasks in South Ossetia andAbkhazia.
"Russian military inspectors have been dealing with the Vostok battalioncases possess data on about involvement of special-task servicemen in anumber of kidnappings and subsequent brutal murders in Chechnya. Vostokbattalion troops conducted a ‘special military operation’ in theBorozdinovskaya village in the summer of 2005. Four houses were burntdown, 11 people disappeared and a 77-year-old man died as a result ofthe operation.Vostok battalion was formed on the basis of the specialplatoon of the Chechen military commandant.The Vostok battalion and its Zapad counterpart were established in 2003.
They are affiliated with the Defense Ministry's 42nd Motorized RifleDivision that is permanently stationed in Chechnya, and are at the sametime directly subordinate to Russian military intelligence (GRU).

Tuesday 12 August 2008

President Bush Discusses Situation in Georgia

For Immediate Release

Office of the Press Secretary
August 11, 2008
President Bush Discusses Situation in Georgia
THE PRESIDENT: I just met with my national security team to discuss thesituation in Georgia.I am deeply concerned by reports that Russian troops have moved beyondthe zone of conflict, attacked the Georgian town of Gori, and arethreatening the Georgia's -- Georgia's capital of Tbilisi. There'sevidence that Russian forces may soon begin bombing the civilian airportin the capital city.
It now appears that an effort may be underway to depose Russia's* dulyelected government. Russia has invaded a sovereign neighboring state andthreatens a democratic government elected by its people. Such an actionis unacceptable in the 21st century.
The Georgian government has accepted the elements of a peace agreementthat the Russian government previously said it would be willing toaccept: an immediate cease-fire, the withdrawal of forces from the zoneof conflict, a return to the military status quo as of August 6th, and acommitment to refrain from using force. There are representatives of theEuropean Union and the Organization for Security and Cooperation inEurope currently in Moscow seeking Russia's agreement to this peace plan.
Russia's government must respect Georgia's territorial integrity andsovereignty. The Russian government must reverse the course it appearsto be on, and accept this peace agreement as a first step towardresolving this conflict.Russia's actions this week have raised serious questions about itsintentions in Georgia and the region. These actions have substantiallydamaged Russia's standing in the world. And these actions jeopardizeRussians' relations -- Russia's relations with the United States andEurope. It is time for Russia to be true to its word and to act to endthis crisis.
Thank you.
END 5:24 P.M. EDT*Georgia's duly elected government

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2008/08/20080811-1.html

Brzezinski: Russia's Invasion of Georgia Is Reminiscent of Stalin's Attack on Finland

NATHAN GARDELS

Brzezinski: Russia's Invasion of Georgia Is Reminiscent of Stalin's Attack on Finland
Posted August 10, 2008 03:49 PM (EST)
On Sunday I talked with Zbigniew Brzezinski, the elder statesman whowas national security advisor to President Jimmy Carter, about theRussian invasion of Georgia. He long tangled with Soviet power. Now hetakes on Putin:Nathan Gardels:
What is the world to make of Russia's invasion of Georgia?Zbigniew Brzezinski: Fundamentally at stake is what kind of role Russia will play in the new international system. Unfortunately, Putinis putting Russia on a course that is ominously similar to Stalin'sand Hitler's in the late 1930s. Swedish foreign minister Carl Bildthas correctly drawn an analogy between Putin's "justification" fordismembering Georgia -- because of the Russians in South Ossetia -- toHitler's tactics vis a vis Czechoslovakia to "free" the Sudeten Deutsch.
Even more ominous is the analogy of what Putin is doing vis-a-visGeorgia to what Stalin did vis-a-vis Finland: subverting by use offorce the sovereignty of a small democratic neighbor. In effect,morally and strategically, Georgia is the Finland of our dayThe question the international community now confronts is how torespond to a Russia that engages in the blatant use of force withlarger imperial designs in mind: to reintegrate the former Sovietspace under the Kremlin's control and to cut Western access to theCaspian Sea and Central Asia by gaining control over the Baku/ Ceyhanpipeline that runs through Georgia.In brief, the stakes are very significant.
At stake is access to oilas that resource grows ever more scarce and expensive and how a majorpower conducts itself in our newly interdepedent world, conduct thatshould be based on accommodation and consensus, not on brute force.If Georgia is subverted, not only will the West be cut off from theCaspian Sea and Central Asia. We can logically anticipate that Putin,if not resisted, will use the same tactics toward the Ukraine. Putinhas already made public threats against Ukraine.Gardels: What, if anything, can the West do to contain this revivedRussian behavior?Brzezinski: Not only the West, but the rest of the internationalcommunity, must make it clear that this kind of behavior will resultin ostracism and economic and financial penalties. Ultimately, ifRussia continues on this course, it must face isolation in theinternational community -- a longer range risk to its own well-being.
The United States, particularly, shoulders the major burden ofmobilizing an collective international response. This invasion ofGeorgia by Russia is a very sad commentary on eight years ofself-delusion in the White House regarding Putin and his regime. Twomemorable comments stand out. First, when Bush first met Putin andsaid he looked into his soul and could trust him. Second, not longago, Condi Rice claimed that American relations with Russia have neverbeen better in history!Gardels: John McCain has already suggested that Russia be expelledfrom the G8. Is that something you would contemplate?Brzezinski:
The G8 is an impotent fiction anyway. But It has to bemuch more thanthat. It has to be a concerted effort on all levels -- at the UnitedNations, in the Atlantic Council, in the EU or in NATO, inconsultation with the Japanese, the Chinese and others -- to convey toRussia that, whatever grievances it may have, it cannot resolve themby a deliberate policy of dismembering an adjoining state andtrying to obtain political domination over it.Gardels: Is the West obliged to help Georgia resist the Russian attackwith some kind of military support?Brzezinski:
The question is not what obligation the West may have atthe moment. The question is about our longer term interest. If aRussia, which misjudges its power and its capacities embarks now on ablatantly nationalistic and imperialistic course, we will all suffer.Therefore it is all the more important that Russia be stopped now bymobilizing a concerted, global effort to oppose and condemn theRussian invasion. Ultimately, that could lead to economic andfinancial sanctions, though one would hope that other Russian leaders,including its business elite, will have cooler heads and be more awareof Russia's own vulnerabilities. Russia is not ready to sustain a newcold war.Gardels: Should the Atlantic Alliance urgently induct Georgia intoNATO as one response?
Brzezinski: The West desisted from extending the NATO "membershipaction plan" to Georgia -- a preparatory stage for becoming a member-- out of deference to Russian objections. It is now clear that thedeference shown to Putin, in the face of his obvious ambitions, hasbeen counterproductive. In view of what has happened, NATO ought toextend the membership action plan to Georgia, therefore reinforcingthe commitment NATO made in Bucharest last Marchto the effect that NATO intends, at some future point, to include Georgia.Gardels: You haven't mentioned Dmitri Medvedev, the the Russianpresident, once, but only Putin.
Does Medvedev have any function in this?Brzezinski: As much to do with it as the formal head of state of theSoviet Union in 1950 had to do with the running of the Sovietgovernment. Does anyone remember his name? But the real ruler of theSoviet Union had a name that most still remember -- and it rhymes withPutin.....